My Honest Stitch Fix Review {Winter 2020}

 

stitch fix honest review winter 2020

 

I’ve mentioned Stitch Fix a few times on the blog before. You can read my honest stitch fix review from previous seasons here and here. It’s literally been a few years since I received my last box, so when Stitch Fix reached out to me with a waived styling fee, I wanted to take advantage of it and try this service again.

 

What is Stitch Fix?

But before we get to my honest stitch fix review, let me tell you what Stitch Fix is (and if you are already familiar, go ahead and scroll down). Stitch Fix is a personal shopping service that shops for you and delivers five pieces of clothing and/or accessories to your door for you to try. You can schedule your deliveries monthly or on-demand.

The charge for the monthly styling fee is $20. If you decide not to keep anything, you send it back in a prepaid envelope and are charged the styling fee. If you keep one or more pieces, the $20 styling fee is credited towards your purchase, and if you purchase all five pieces, you receive a 25% discount. You can try Stitch Fix using my code to get $25 off your first fix!

I let my stylist know that I worked from home and wanted pieces that were casual yet easy to put together for when I had to run out. I also asked for items that would transition from winter to spring. I shared my try-on on my Instastories and had you vote for if they were keepers or not.

 

My Honest Stitch Fix Review – What was in my Latest Box:

Mix By 41 Hawthorn – Denver Front Twist Brushed Knit Top – $38

I would say this is a sweater, not a top. The material is really soft, and I liked how it fit, but the 3/4 sleeves take away the cozy factor. Plus, I would prefer a longer length to wear with leggings. I think it would look cute with a jean jacket layered over it in the spring. 66% voted to keep it, but in the end, I decided to return it.

 

Cozy Twist Front Top

 

August Mix – Josey Elbow Patch Pullover $46

I’m a sucker for elbow patches, and the honeycomb knit is really cute. It’s a heavier weight knit and pretty versatile. You could wear it with leggings, jeans, or skinny trousers and it would be darling with a vest layered over it. 60% said this was a keeper, but because I didn’t absolutely love it, I returned it.

 

Winter Stitch Fix Elbow Patch Sweater

 

Jolie – Reid 3/4 Sleeve Knit Top $38

I had high hopes for this one when I pulled it out of the box. The teal color is gorgeous, and I generally like the look of batwing sleeves. But, this top is not very flattering on me, and 87% of you agreed!

 

Dolman Sleeve Sweater

 

Lush – Warren Split-Neck Blouse $44

This cute cheetah print top was my favorite piece in the box, and this type of top is something that can be worn with virtually everything. It would be easy to dress this up or down. 80% of you said it was a keeper, but I already have a cheetah print top. As much as I love animal print, having two similar tops in my closet makes no sense, so this one didn’t make the cut and was returned.

 

Cheetah Print Top

 

Sophie Rue – Demeter Cardigan $48

How pretty is this cardigan layered over the cheetah print top? It’s a wool blend, and the neutral color and length of this cardigan are perfect. I have a very similar cardigan already, so this was returned as well.

 

Rust Open Front Cardigan Winter Stitch Fix

 

Stitch Fix Final Thoughts

Even though I didn’t end up keeping anything, I thought overall this was still a good box and I had fun trying everything on. The pieces were of high quality, and the price points wouldn’t break the bank. Unfortunately, it just didn’t have any unique pieces that wowed me or that I couldn’t find anywhere else. I definitely recommend them if you are looking to update your wardrobe with a few key pieces or to treat yourself by having someone shop for you. I think it’s important to really communicate your likes/dislikes and what you are specifically looking for with your stylist. You can try Stitch Fix yourself using my code to get $25 off your first fix! 

 

 

Stitch Fix Review Winter 2020

 

I hope you enjoyed my honest Stitch Fix review!

As always, thank you for reading!

If you liked this post, you can subscribe here or follow me on Feedly | Bloglovin | Instagram Pinterest Facebook

Linking up here.

Now onto the linkup! I can’t wait to see your outfits!

Welcome to Thursday Fashion Files! Carrie, at Curly Crafty Momand I are excited to have you here and would love to have you link up one of your latest outfits with us at the bottom of this post. Don’t forget to check out our Thursday Fashion Files Pinterest board and click HERE if you’d like to contribute!

 

Follow Jill:

Bloglovin’FacebookInstagramPinterestFeedlyLIKEtoKNOW.it

 

Follow Carrie:

Bloglovin’FacebookTwitterInstagramPinterest

Link Up Guidelines:

1. Feel free to grab our button to display on your blog sidebar. Help spread the word and share about our link up community.

2. **By adding your links, you are stating that you have the proper licensing/rights to the images in your blog posts.**
3. 

 

My Pick from Last Week’s LinkUp:

 

 

My favorite outfit from last week is Shelly from The Queen In Between! Her top is so beautiful and I can’t resist a pop of leopard! 

 

 

You are invited to the Inlinkz link party!

Click here to enter


Sharing is caring!


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

38 responses

  1. Kellyann

    I enjoyed my first Stitch Fix box and look forward to another one this spring. While I liked your box I didn’t LOVE it so I voted for you to return it all – I would have liked to have seen brighter colors. It was a good box just not a great one! This was fun to see and I really enjoyed it on stories!
    xo,
    Kellyann

  2. I really liked the printed top and the rust cardi – it’s a shame you didn’t keep anything but good that the stylist got it so right and you actually already had similar pieces in your wardrobe as they are so you! 🙂

    Thanks for the link up!

    Hope you’re having a nice week 🙂

    Away From Blue

  3. These are really great staple pieces but like you said if you already have similar pieces or it’s not exactly what you want, why clutter up valuable closet space, right?

    Shelbee
    http://www.shelbeeontheedge.com

  4. I really like the pieces you got and I’d love to try StitchFix at some point, so I’ll remember your link here for sure. I’m not a fan of 3/4 sleeves either. I like long sleeves that I can roll up or push up, but to me, a sweater with 3/4 sleeves is like a sleeveless sweater dress. I just don’t get them :/ It’s too bad they didn’t send you anything new you could fall in love with or didn’t already have. I guess you described yourself too well to the stylist. I really loved that blue top and it looked great with the rust cardigan but I agree about having too many similar things in the closet. But I also know what you mean about just having fun trying everything on even if you aren’t keeping it. I do monthly giveaways and two of the things I giveaway are my Ipsy Glam Bag and my Allure Beauty Box for the month. Even though I don’t get to keep the beauty goodies any more, I still enjoy going through everything and reading about their benefits. Thank you so much for the link-up!

    Ruth
    https://voguefauxreal.com/2020/02/06

  5. Rach

    I love how honesty about not keeping the items. In my opinion, I think you look great in most of the tops! The color of that cardigan though is gorgeous!

    http://www.rdsobsessions.com

  6. Love this honest review! I do like that cheetah blouse, but if you weren’t loving it, by all means return!

    xx, Elise
    http://www.sparkleandslippers.blogspot.com

  7. I think Stitch Fix always shows cute pieces on their social media but then they send other stuff. It’s one reason I stopped receiving Fixes. I like the very first top in this Fix, but the rest is nothing special like you said. Have you heard about their new feature where you can directly buy something and not get a Fix? I saw lots of cute things and was very tempted, but I haven’t purchased anything as I’m trying to save money.

  8. I love that you are honest about this review, its very important and I love the last 2 🙂 xx

  9. Ellibelle

    These really are some cute pieces they sent you and fit you so well. But it’s also understandable why you didn’t keep anything, like you said, they are not such unique pieces.
    Thanks for hosting the linkup!
    Ellibelle’s Corner

  10. I often come across bloggers trying the Stitch & Fix. I find it interesting to see the choices made. They did good! xx

  11. I love that cardigan and the leopard print top. Sorry that nothing ended up working in the end for you though. I try on things at work all of the time but if I don’t love it or really need it then I don’t buy it! 🙂 We also have a similar service at Evereve called Trendsend. 🙂

  12. The denver top is super cute and I love the cardigan. those were my favorites and I like how you assessed why or why you wouldn’t keep the items. Sometimes we get things just to get them. Nice rundown Jill!

  13. The last two pieces are my faves! They are such a great combo together. Thanks for sharing this box and for the link up. Have a wonderful Valentine’s Day Jill!

    https://www.kathrineeldridge.com

  14. Great looks Jill, I love that rust cardigan. Rust and black are one of my favorite color combos.
    Nora

  15. Mireille

    I like that you can receive a box and be smart about what is worth adding to your closet. Sometimes we get stuck in the wanting of something new, we get things that we don’t need or are too similar to what we have.
    http://www.chezmireillefashiontravelmom.com

  16. Sorry none of the pieces worked for you, but I couldn’t agree more that if it’s not a big win there’s no reason to keep it <3

    Green Fashionista

  17. Federica Di Nardo

    You look good in blue!

    Federica
    http://www.federicadinardo.com

  18. All of these are such beautiful pieces! I really love the split-neck blouse.

    Make Life Marvelous

  19. Such cute outfits! I’ve never heard of Stitch Fix before, but it sounds like such a great concept xo

    Makeup Muddle

  20. Biana Perez

    I really like the brown cardigan in the last photo, but sometimes when you’re just not feeling it you’re not feeling it!!

  21. I only tried Stitch Fix once Jill, but that’s how I felt. Nothing really stood out and caught my fancy (and the price point was a tad high). If you want to try Fashom, they have a Feb. deal where you get $20 from my link. Let me know…I’ve had much better luck with them.
    XOXO
    Jodie

  22. I can see why none of those things were keepers. Nothing looked very spring-like, either.

  23. This box has a lot more affordable pieces than they typically do! I haven’t tried Stitch Fix because of the cost of the clothing, but it’s good to know they seem to be using more affordable items. I really like the leopard top and cardigan!

  24. I took a little break from Stitch Fix, but when I look in my closet, I find lots of cute things from them. So maybe it’s time for a new one! Your pieces are very nice! The brown cardigan looks cute and cozy!

    Thanks for sharing,
    xx Darlene

  25. Shauna C

    I think everything is so super cute! I especially like the brown cardigan. It looks so cozy cute on you.

    Shauna

    http://www.lipglossandlace.net

  26. Love these winter pieces!Super cute and cozy!
    Nice Post! Have a great day!
    Allurerage
    Rampdiary

  27. Amber Rathvon

    These are all super cute and cozy winter pieces, but that blue cheetah top is my favorite!

    I hope you have a fabulous week!

    Amber

    Visit AvecAmber.com

    Follow Avec Amber on Bloglovin

  28. The blouse and the cardigan are lovely. It’s a a shame you didn’t have anything in the box that wowed you though.

    Emma xxx
    http://www.style-splash.com

  29. Some good pieces, it’s a brilliant idea. Jacqui x

  30. I recently received a Stitch Fix box where I returned everything, but I’ve had boxes where I’ve kept everything, too!

  31. I’m sorry you didn’t end up keeping anything, Jill, but agree there were some beautiful pieces in this box. Shame we don’t have this sort of service in Australia, I feel like I would enjoy trying on pieces picked out by someone else. Fun!!

  32. This seems like such a fun service to get to try new styles- they all look great on you!

  33. wow love the sound of personal shopping service! great outfits! xx
    Elegant Duchess xx
    https://www.elegantduchess.com/

  34. These tops and cardigan looks so amazing. My favorite is blue one. I need to check them.

    New Post – https://www.exclusivebeautydiary.com/2020/02/elizabeth-arden-prevage-anti-aging_15.html

  35. All cute pieces but most of them are a little ‘spendier’ than my pocket book allows. I kept 3 pieces from my last box but probably should have kept one. It is such fun to get a box, isn’t it? And I get all caught up in that!

  36. These are all so cute and cozy on you dear. The 2nd sweater is definitely my fave. Really pretty color!

    Jessica | notjessfashion.com

  37. Such a fun box! The cheetah print top is my favourite too, but definitely not worth keeping if you have a similar one!
    Julia x
    https://www.thevelvetrunway.com/

  38. It was a good box, but good for you not keeping something just because. XO